ButcherBox Review – (And a Promo Code!)

healthy body

Read my honest Butcher Box review and learn the pros and cons of this popular meat delivery service. Is Butcherbox for you? Find out!

January 25, 2021
This post may contain affiliate links. Please read my disclosure and privacy policy.

I thought it’s about time I share my ButcherBox review with you all! I’ve been a ButcherBox member for a few years now, so I’ve got a good understanding about how it works…and some pros and cons.

So without further ado, here is my honest review for this delivery subscription service!

Looking for a ButcherBox promo code? Sign up today and get free meat!

If you’d rather save $50 off your first ButcherBox order CLICK HERE

butcher box review

Is Butcherbox worth it?

I was drawn to ButcherBox meat delivery for a variety of reasons. One being I couldn’t find a good price on grass fed beef and humanely raised meat near me.

I loved that I could get high quality meat delivered straight to my door. It’s basically like having an online butcher!

There’s something about not having to buy meat at the grocery store that’s pretty magical.

ButcherBox Review – What Is It?

ButcherBox is essentially an online meat delivery service offering high quality meats and sea food. ButcherBox partners with farmers all over the U.S. who live up to high standards to provide healthy meat to the 48 contiguous states.

butcher box review

ButcherBox Review – What Meat Do They Offer?

ButcherBox offers a variety of meats to pick from. Here’s the current list of products they offer:

100% grass fed grass finished beef

  • burgers
  • grass fed ground beef
  • ground sirloin
  • top sirloin steak
  • flat iron steak
  • tri-tip
  • chuck roast
  • stew beef
  • bottom of the round roast
  • filet mignons
  • shoulder roast
  • NY strip steaks
  • sirloin cap
  • ranch steaks
  • premium steak tips

Free range organic chicken

  • whole free range chicken
  • boneless skinless chicken breasts
  • bone-in chicken thighs
  • chicken drumsticks

Heritage breed pork

  • St. Louis ribs
  • boneless pork loin chops
  • ground pork
  • baby back ribs
  • pork tenderloin
  • boneless pork butt
  • bacon

Wild caught sea food

  • Alaskan sockeye salmon
  • salmon burgers
  • cod

And more!

  • ground turkey
  • uncured hot dogs
  • ground bison

ButcherBox Review – How It Works

If you’re nervous about ordering meat online, don’t be! ButcherBox makes ordering meat a breeze. Their website is easy to use and they have great customer service if you ever have any questions.

How ButcherBox works:

Step 1: Set up an account. You can use this link to receive free meat!

Step 2: Choose your subscription type. Choose between:

  • Custom Box
  • Mixed Curated Box
  • Beef and Chicken
  • Beef and Pork
  • All beef

I always go with the custom box so I can choose exactly what cuts of meat I want. If you’re content having ButcherBox send you whatever cuts they have, go for the other boxes – you’ll save a little money too!

butcher box review

Step 3: Choose your box size:

Classic Box (9-14 lbs.)
Big Box (18-26 lbs.)

Step 4: Choose your billing date. This is customizable according to your needs and can be changed in your account settings at any time.

Step 5: Choose the frequency you want your box delivery to occur. The options are every 2, 4, 6, and 8 weeks. This setting can also be changed at any time in your account settings. I like getting my box every month.

Step 6: Add any other items you may want from the “member deals” section and checkout to complete your box order!

Click here to get free meat!

ButcherBox Review – Butcher Box Prices

ButcherBox prices vary depending on what size box you get, and what add-ons you may have in your box.

But here are the general prices:

Classic Box – $159.00 which comes to about $11.35-$17.66 per pound
Big Box – $288.00 which comes to about $11.07-$16 per pound

The above prices are for a “custom box.” If you want to go with the “curated box” option, you’ll save some money!

butcher box review

The Pros:

Easy to order
High quality
Ships right to your door
They often run promotions. These vary but for example, I recently payed a one time fee of 25$ and now I get a pack of free bacon in each box for the life of my membership! They always offer some sort of discount code for your first order.
Packed with dry ice to ensure freshness
Customizable – change your billing date, box size, meat cuts and more at any time in your account settings!
Great customer service
They offer member deals
Easily cancel if it’s not for you!

The Cons:

Packaging of the actual meat is not the best. I always have some packages in every box that leak when I thaw them. I learned that the hard way when the raw meat juice leaked all over my fridge.

To combat this I always make sure to thaw the meat in a container to catch any juice that might leak. I definitely wish the packaging was better but it’s not a deal breaker for me.

It can be pricey. For me, but not everyone, ButcherBox is a bit of a splurge – but it’s one that’s worth it. Feeding my family high quality food is really important to me, and it’s worth the price. And unfortunately do to supply issues, they recently raised their prices.

I wish in general that healthy food was cheaper.  But I’ve accepted that it’s not and we budget for it.

The meat can be delivered late – which unfortunately means the meat can be thawed upon delivery.  But fear not!  ButcherBox will always replace any meat that isn’t frozen to a safe temperature when it arrives at your door.

A late box is usually not the fault of the meat delivery subscription but more-so the postal carrier. Sometimes things happen that are out of our control so it’s best just to go with the flow on this one and replace any meat that didn’t arrive frozen.

butcher box review

Final Thoughts

Is Butcher box worth it? Overall, I highly recommend ButcherBox. The pros heavily outweigh the cons for me, and I’ve been very happy with the quality of the meat! The taste says it all.

And let’s be honest, having it shipped right to your door is pretty awesome.

Once you’re a member, keep your eyes peeled for coupons, Butcher Box offers for discount meat and member deals. Free shipping is always included.

Let me know your thoughts, or ask me any questions below about this meat delivery subscription box!

Recipes To Make With Your Butcher Box Meat!

Healthy Pineapple Chicken

Paleo Steak Bites 

Pineapple Chicken Fajitas

Simple Stuffed Peppers

pin for later icon

butcher box review

Looking for verified Butcher Box promo codes for 2022? Click here to receive free meat! 


CLICK HERE to save 30$ off your first ButcherBox order!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *